Here are our recommendations for the best prostate massagers, vibrators, and other toys on the market. Prostate stimulation 101 use an anal toy there are all sorts of anal toys to bring the pleasure of prostate stimulation into your solo or coupled love life. However, it can be tough to narrow down and choose just one anal toy, especially if youre just getting started, but have your sights set on working your way up in size to a larger toy or penis. Try different sized anal toys or get a longer one that you can insert as deep as your bottom desires. You can buy prostate massagers that offer up multiple speed and pulse settings.